Sorrento Pizzeria

A community favorite, I’ve come here many times! Pizzeria section up front. Dining room next door feels cozy and nostalgic. Great menu, consistent quality Italian American. Fast friendly service. Comparable pricing to elsewhere in the area. Recommend them for dinner and take-out.

My family all have dietary restrictions. My brother vegetarian, sister had many food allergies and I'm just plain picky. Sorento's always has plenty for anyone dining with us. This is the safest place and fortunately the most delicious too.

The garlic knots are amazing and inexpensive. The Buffalo pizza was very good and the crust was perfect.

Visited the area for 2 weeks. Came here for two meals, and came back 4 additional times for the Dirty Martinis. Best place in town for pizza and martinis.

We stopped in for lunch after riding 30 miles from Rome on the Erie Canal Trail. Appetizer was a loaded tater tots dish, yowza! Delicious, just enough to whet the appetites of thred bicyclists. Next a full Caesar salad, very nice. Finally a half order of rigatoni (the "riggie"), delicious and plenty of food. I could not have eaten a full order. Did I say finally? We finished of with a slice of pumpkin cheesecake (a little 4" cheesecake all by itself) topped with nuts and whipped cream. Mmmm. Great food, friendly waitstaff, reasonable prices. Excellent value!

I always get Chicken Riggies when I'm at Sorrento for dinner. This time I tried the Buffalo Chicken Riggies and man oh man are they amazing. I've been coming here since I was a kid and the Magro family has kept the same sauce and recipes going all these years. They take care of the kids that come in for a slice and coke even after all these years. The pizza is unparalleled to anywhere else and is a must try. You won't be di as appointed.

Our favorite restaurant! We make this establishment a regular stop when we are in the Utica area. We especially enjoy their lunch specials. Their antipasto is Chuck full with meat, cheese, peppers, tomatoes, and red onion, and topped with a balsamic dressing unlike anything found anywhere else. I get the eggplant sandwich and my wife gets the BLT. Our waitress is absolutely the best and has been there for a long time. She remembers our orders and knows other requests we have. Always nice to see her. We are going to try their pizza which looks great and on special on Tuesdays but we haven’t yet. We highly recommended this wonderful Italian restaurant!! Update we tried the pizza today and it was excellent. Sausage and peppers with close to a perfect crust. Best we have had around Utica. This pizza was perfect for an air fryer(in warm ups) as good if not better than first consumed!

Awesome Italian, huge portions and great staff, always try to stop by on our way thru the area

Clean, great service and food. At first glance we saw the care they took in designing the interior and keeping it clean. The employees then kindly took our order making us fee like friends. Once we tasted the amazing food we knew we would return.

The food was fantastic, our server was fantastic! Great atmosphere! Pat, the owner, came out to meet us and greeted us like old friends or family! We will be coming back!

Came in 45 minutes before closing, everyone was happy to seat us. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive, the food came out quickly and was delicious!

Fresh, tasty good food. Engaging waitress who knows her food

Great pizza, best in the area. Outstanding service and large menu to pick from.

Best restaurant in town!
Whether you’re a local or visiting, you won’t find a better place to eat. I had their signature Utica Greens, and a grilled chicken spinach salad. Both were prepared to order, the service was excellent, and the restaurant was very clean and well maintained. The garlic bread was excellent as well. You’ll find all of your Italian favorites here.

Sorrento's is our family go to for Italian cuisine in the Herkimer area! So grateful for their consistency 🍕🙏❤

Great customer service and food, meatballs and pizza spot on, a place to have a nice dinner in Ilion!

They have great lunch specials. Riggies $8, Greens $8, They also have sandwish and soup/salad for $10. Great deals. The regular menu is also available. I got the Chicken stir fry over rice sauteed with white wine and garlic. It was fantastic and I had enough to take home for lunch the next day. The waitperson was very nice and efficient. The dining room was packed at lunch and it seemed like she was everywhere.

Great Pizza! Very consistent, very good food. Its definitely a go to if want delicious food everytime you order. They do a great job here from great food to great service, Highly Recommend!

We went to the restaurant for our granddaughter's 1st birthday. It was wonderful. Food was so good . . Our waitress was amazing. Thank you for a memorable evening.

To be honest we haven't received our food yet. It took 25 min for the waitress to come but it was really busy. Food and service has always been good here but today the atmosphere isn't so great because it's soooo freaking cold in here! People are trying to cover their arms. AC must be set to Arctic blast. Feels like a meat cooler! It's usually cool in here hence we wore long sleeve shirts even though it's 80 out. But today it's much much colder. We actually contemplated leaving. How do they not notice all the customers all wearing jackets or trying to cover up their arms? Come on now...when the waitress asked how we were I said freezing.. apparently fell on deaf ears cause I got no response back. (Update)Two out of three entrees were good. Salads were not good at all. Would I advise not going there? No. This is the first time our experience wasn't good. I would advise wearing a thick hoodie or warm jacket and definitely pants. Overall I'm chucking this one up to them being busy and probably understaffed in the kitchen.