Cindy's Pies

Fresh pie, that filled our car with amazing smells that was vegan. I can’t believe it. On a rainy may day this was amazing. Can’t wait to come back for more.

If you want a homemade pie that is extremely fresh stop in here! We got a baby tart to eat immediately because I literally couldn’t wait and then got a large grape pie.
Very clean professional and high end bakery that Cranks out some of the best pies you’ve ever had !

Delicious! Wonderful customer service & the pies were so flavorful! We were grateful for a free sample & bought cherry cookies and a cherry pie. We were told the business has been around for about fifty years - incredible.

I didn’t think I was going to like the grape pie, since I had tried one from another place in the past and wasn’t impressed. Theirs was honestly so good. The right balance of sweet and tart with a delicious, flaky crust. The grape filled cookies are so good too.

Stopped in curious to try the Grape Pie. You can get either crumb or regular top we got the crumb It was absolutely spectacular and still warm. We will be stopping to grab a few before we start our drive home to Pa. We also grabbed two cherry tarts to eat in the car on the way to our air b&b which were also delish!!! If you’re in the area make Cindy’s a must try!!

Cindy's are really the best grape pies in the town. We get them annually! Also, love the raspberry and cherry tarts.

Been coming here since I was a child, best pies in Naples. A little more $ than some, but delicious pies and cookies!

I may be in the minority, but the real sleeper here is the maple pie/tart. The grape pies are delicious and filled with that rich, grapey, jamminess that makes this place a local gem, but the maple... Truly I celebrate their entire selection and this is the best grape pie place in Naples, possibly the whole of the finger lakes. The owners are cool as heck, too.

Oh baby these pies are tremendous. Got a grape pie and raspberry pie. Haven’t tried the raspberry one yet but the grape one was so good I had to hop on here and preach about it. Still warm, fresh out the oven, mouth watering grape goodness. Reminded me of my first thanks giving when I tried welches sparkling grape juice. So much delicious grape flavor but instead of a beverage it’s a pie. All for the low low price of 14 dollars.

Vacationing from out of state and enjoying the local wines?
Then you need to try the grape pie or at least the cookies, simply amazing and delicious!

My favorite grape pie! Also love the grape filled cookies. My wife and I have a cabin in the area and always tell our friends we will bring them back some, but the pies never make it that long! They disappear as soon as we get home!

First time trying grape pie, loved it.. Getting pies for Thanksgiving 🤗

Cindy's is a fixture of Naples for good reason.
I only regret it took me this long to try it their wares, specifically their pies
Their double-flake pie crusts are slightly crisp without being brittle, and complement their filling.
As for the filling, their grape pies are superb as one would hope to find in Naples. Sweet, fresh, and solid. It cuts easily with a fork without running.
Try it with a scoop of vanilla greek yogurt!

Their raspberry pie is satisfyingly tart, and looser in consistency by nature (raspberries never want to stick together). You can't go wrong with either choice.

My family and I stopped in and got a strawberry rhubarb and a chicken pot pie. Both tasted very fresh with quality ingredients. The crust though really made the pies wonderful. Next time I'm in Naples, I will definitely stop in again!

Absolutely the BEST Grape Pies. I especially like the crumb top grape pie...out of this world !!! We come up from West Point and look forward to stopping at Cindy's and stocking up on pies and goodies. We haven't been there since pre-Covid. But we cannot wait !!!

Her pumpkin pie is wonderful, so tasty and full of spices. The cranberry apple pie was outstanding!! The best I had ever tasted. The crust she makes does not overpower the filling, but blends with it. I also highly recommend the cutout cookies....just like Grandma used to make!

Have you tried their grape sandwich cookies? Yes, this is a pie shop, so I was not expecting their cookies to be delicious. If you are a long time fan of Cindy's Pies, you already know how foolish that was. These things are so good they should be illegal. This small town, small business run by a kind hearted, friendly, fun young couple is a must stop if you are within 50 miles of their door step. Dale Ottosen, Auburn, NY

I've never tried a grape pie until today at The Grapefest. Fortunately for me, I was left with an incredibly great first impression. We went back for more pies and unsurprisingly they were sold out. Our feet were tired so we went back to the car and then decided to try Monica's Pies just down the road. We've past it over the years and expected some of that similar delicious taste. Unfortunately this simply was not the case at all and Monica needs to go back to the drawing board in my opinion. The filling was unfulfilling and seemed to taste like artificial pie filling from a can. Nothing fresh and organic tasting like Cindy's Pies. We want to go back, and real soon to stock up and also try other pies they may have. I read sad news that Cindy's Pies is for sale. I didn't pay much attention to the sign out front. This is awful news and one can only hope that a future prospective owner doesn't change one darn thing regarding these pies. They are perfect! Don't fix what ain't broke as they say. Thanks for listening!

We have always bought our grape pies from Cindy in Naples New York. They are the best! Flaky crusts and totally tasty great pie filling

Had never even heard of Grape pie before...my boyfriend took me there on our valentine's day trip and i fell in love with it! We will definitely be repeat customers!💜😀