John's Wildwood Pizzeria

Nice little pizza parlor. Pizza is surprisingly good. Just really tasty. I believe they use muenster cheese mixed with provolone. The pizza crust is good , kind of chewy, not hard and crunchy. Good amount of toppings. There are only 2 or 3 tables unfortunately. But the service was good. I want to go back soon.

I went to college here, visited friends in edinboro when I was in highschool, and now I'm an adult, living 2 hours away. I will always crave John's, and in all those years, after a fire, they've never lost quality. This is still the best pizza I've ever had. I'm convinced, it'll never lose that title.

The first place I stop when visiting home. I have been around the world and had pizza in some form everywhere. This is definitely my favorite.

Always satisfied when we order from here!!

I got laughed at when I ordered $80.00 worth of food for a bunch of starving children LOL And as always John Wildwoods Saves the Day! My absolute favorite pizza place I worked here when I was in college I'm so happy that they are back open!!

The best pizza in Erie County by a good amount :)

John’s is probably one of the best pizza places in Pennsylvania! Very slept on spot but definitely give them a taste, it’s 100% quality service and fast delivery 🤝🏽

We're staying at the Comfort Inn and when asked about pizza delivery, your name came up as being really good! You did not disappoint!! Everything tasted amazing! And provided plates and napkins which was awesome! Thank you!

Stopped here on our way to Pittsburgh. Our pizzas were delicious and the staff super nice to us. Thank you very much!

When my husband and I moved to this area 10 months ago, one of the first orders of business was to find a good pizza shop. We tried all the ones close by, and all the recommended spots from locals, and were disappointed that every place was more than 'not that great' - they were all gross. Store bought dough, overly sweet sauces, and over processed cheeses. After 10 months and trying close to 2 dozen shops, we were ready to resign ourselves to having to make pizza at home if we wanted it at all.

Then we found John's.

This pizza is not only good, it's perfect. It's exactly what NY style pizza should be - fresh, thin stretched dough, perfectly seasoned sauce, and fresh cheese and pepperonis. We are SO thankful to have found John's, and we look forward to trying the entire menu.

So good we went back the next week! Excellent!

Hands down, no contest, the best Pizza I've this side of the state. I cannot recommend this location enough if you want to taste for yourself the best made pizza in Erie County.

On top of pizza, they have incredible wings, and much more. Their honey mustard sauce is unique. This flavor is a staple on most menus but I've never found one that quite matches John's.

If you're driving through, or you live nearby, stopping here is a must.

Great local pizza joint. Highly recommend 👌.

I was 18 and going to college and this place was a rock. I am 36 and this is still a rock for the community. And good food, too. Unlike rocks.

Grew up on John's and always look forward to visiting them on my trips back home. John has always been friendly, and even remembered my family's regular order many years after we moved out of the area. great food, Subs are great, and Calzones are big enough for two meals. Always great service. looking forward to my next visit this summer.

My family does "John's Tuesdays" Pizza and wings.

Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Compares well to traditional New York slices in Brooklyn, and it’s priced just as well. Customer service is great as well.

Top notch place I am from West Virginia and remember eating there

Love John's!!! Always fantastic. My family agrees. Thank you for your delicious pizza!

the pizza was awesome and I really don't like to try new pizza places but we were out of town for the weekend and the wife side it was good and it definitely was thank you to all the helpful and patient employees