Tiffany's Family Restaurant

Wonderful home cooking! Waitress was so accommodating. We called from Shipshewanna to see if they could have a table for 10 set up by the time we got there. Not only was it ready, they had us in a side room by ourselves. It was a special group of family and friends who had not been together for a few years. They helped make it a special evening!

They said things were rough because they just opened up from remodeling. Group table, the food delivered whenever. People done eating, People there first still waiting on food. Hopefully things will improve

Love their salad bar. And the fried chicken is Amish style. Just like grandma used to make.

Yummy and delicious inexpensive food. Customer service was very pleasant. I had a ham and cheese omelette. But, it had American cheese. Ick... I asked for some cheddar and she gladly brought some. We would definitely go again!

First time here ! Best chicken anywhere ! Everything was delicious, all fresh , homemade, the fresh peach pie was scrumptious,! Calm relaxed atmosphere , very good service. Made for a great experience. We will definitely return , it will be our place for chicken.

Update: Had the buffet on 10.8.21

A good deal for the money. A good selection of salad, fruit, and desert along with chicken, noodles, a vegetable, and potatoes and gravy.

Had coffee and sugar free pie for a meeting there.

Always good service!

Really liked it. Ordered 2pc broiled chicken. Came with plenty of fries, a side, and homemade bread. With drinks it's about 12 dollars per person, which is a great price. The chicken was very good, and very friendly and accommodating staff. Over all a very good eat.

Good salad bar, food buffet only had a few items, but items in it were very good, especially the chicken. Desert buffet was good. This is a smaller restaurant and buffet than many if the places in Amish country, but the food and service are good. Good value also.

UPDATE: Back again. This time I tried the Beef Manhattan. So good!! Now I will be torn between the chicken or the Beef Manhattan. Wonderful restaurant slightly off the beaten path but worth it. Don't miss this place!

Small buffet approx $12 per person at this time, but everything is so much fresher and tastier than the big buffets close by that charge a huge price. Save your money, fill your tummy with foods that fresh and tasty and make your tummy smile. The buffet desserts are awesome. My favorite is the Caramel tapioca pudding with Snicker bars in it and the spice cake fluff. Yum

Excellent lunch buffet. This place was recommended by a friend, so we drove an hour to try it.....We were not disappointed, Amish cooking at its best. Homemade mashed potatoes and gravy, vegetables, oven roasted chicken, and more ... Awesome dessert and salad, soup bar.!!! All for less than $50.00 for a family of four. We will definitely be back.!!! Excellent, friendly wait staff.

Home-cooked flavor. The Beef Manhatten and pies are my go to items. Very reasonably priced

My wife, daughter and I had been looking for a decent sit down meal in Shipshewana, none to be found. All buffets and sandwiches. Not exactly what I had in mind. So we found Tiffany's up the road. Well worth the drive. Daughter had the buffet and we had traditional meals. Very good food, great portions and friendly service. Impressed!

Great food and great buffet! 😋

My family has been here multiple times. Its a great alternative to essenhaus and blue gate. But much cheaper. Also less touristy. I usually get the buffet, but the chicken meals come with bread on the regular menu. Their bread is delicious. Highly recommend.

Get the waffle fries with sloppy joe and cheese! Absolutely delicious!!!

Great home cooked meals ,Turkey Manhatten was spectacular!

First time and we'll definitely be back!

Amish authentic go for the pie , service is great

Love this place I go there alot good food

Outstanding food at a great price. The pie was unbelievable (better than anywhere in Shipshewana). Had the Manhattan which was delicious and more than what was expected. Defiantly a go-to for lunch/dinner. I will be back to try the breakfast soon. Service was great too.