Cravings by Brittany Bakery & Boutique

Every item at Brittany's bakery is absolutely delicious! Personal faves include the butter tarts (plain), Hello Dolly bars, Heidi cookies, and the white chocolate almond bars. We love grabbing an assortment of baked goods all year round, and ice cream to enjoy in the nearby park in the summer is an added bonus!

Brittany and her mom are so friendly. They will always greet you with a smile. Such a lovely spot to visit and well worth the 15-20 minute drive from Caistorville! Heck, I'd probably make the drive from Burlington if I still lived there!!

If I had any complaints, they would be that raisin butter tarts aren't an option (I'm sure I'm in the minority that loves raisins!) and sometimes I forget to order ahead and miss out on goodies that sell out quick 😉

Edited to add, because some people take things too literally when they read reviews, those complaints are not actually complaints - totally being cheeky!!!

We had a positively wonderful experience working with Brittany on our wedding cake! As Caledonians, we wanted to work with someone more local for our cake, and we had heard so many incredible things about Brittany and her bakery.

Brittany was professional, attentive, and kind throughout the entire process of creating our dream cake. She was fast to reply to an questions we had for her and worked with us to ensure we were totally happy with the product. She even helped us include our fur baby into our special day by adding our figurine to the cake — and we have to say, the dab of frosting on our pup's nose was a total crowd pleaser. Thank you Brittany for a delicious & beautiful wedding cake! :)

Amazing doesn’t even start to describe how perfect our wedding cake was from Brittany!!! We got a 3 tier vanilla buttercream with raspberry icing and it was to die for! The florals on the cake were so pretty too. So many guests saying how it was the best cake they ever had! I wish I could keep reliving the moment. I would 10000000x Recommend! Thank you so much😍🙏🏻

Brittany makes the most delicious baked goods! I ordered a Red Velvet cake for my Birthday and it was truly amazing. I go there often for baked goods and for buying gifts. Her store has a lot of awesome gift ideas!

100% recommend stopping by for a treat! Fresh baked goods and other locally sourced products. Brittany and her team truly want to put smiles on people's faces and fill their bellies!

Beautiful boutique, lovely ladies and delicious treats. Hello dollies being my favorite! We have been going to Brittney's since she had her scones at the Carolinian. Always amazing!!

I have only ordered mixed treat boxes from Brittany a couple of times but both were delicious. There is a great selection available every week and everything looks amazing. The shop in Cayuga is super cute and there are lots of neat retail items available as well. I would pick something up every week if I lived closer.

WOW ❤ I just had the best ever scone and believe me I’ve had many lol
Today was my first purchase from Cravings by Brittany but definitely not my last!
The scones are just incredibly delicious, and appashe does quite the variety ❤
The chip bars are just wonderful with a cup of tea and the cookies are totally amazing!
Everything was so very fresh I could still enjoy the aroma.
Brittany thank you for sharing your talent 🍪🍰🥧🧁❤

Cravings by Brittany is the yummiest and friendliest bakery around!! You cannot beat the variety of treats they always have available, as well as scooping ice cream and having collaborations to bring in other bakers or goods you can purchase for gifts. This bakery really caters to all cravings! I personally love their scones and their butter tarts are always a win across any family or friend get together that I’ve brought them to. On top of the treats being amazing, the service is always amazing too. You’re always greeted with a friendly face from Brittany and her mom! We’re so lucky to have this bakery in Haldimand County.

Ordered a Red Velvet cake. It was made on time, it was ready for me to pick up and it was the best cake we have eaten!
Brittany has got herself a great place with even better baked goods - We look forward to our next cake order - stay tuned!
It’s worth the drive to Cayuga! Make the trip!! Treat yourself!!!

My wife made me drive to Cayuga to check out this little place and we walked out with some baked goods and I grabbed a coffee. The butter tarts were excellent, my daughter raved about her cupcake and the coffee was very good. We will definitely return. Thanks!

Love this shop!

I love the cafe crema! I’ve also tried a few of the sweet items - pumpkin pie tart, apple tarts, the cheesecake.. everything was so fresh (which really matters to me) and so so good! My kids love to go there for ice cream! All of her reviews are 5 stars for a reason, Brittany and her mom work so hard and it shows. The shop is so well decorated and clean, she has lots of cool stuff from local vendors and artisans as well.

LOVE Cravings by Brittany! My go to for any sweet treat! Her sweets are top notch, and almost too beautiful to eat!! She's also got a lovely selection of giftware! Her pecan butter tarts are second to none, and a fan favourite in my household! Brittany and her mom are also absolutely delightful humans! I always walk out of this little gem of a shop with a smile on my face! Definitely worth the drive!!

We were given a gift of treats from your shop today, from our favourite neighbours, and everything thing in this wonderful little box was not only beautiful but delicious. Best gift ever! Totally recommend ANY tart the pastry is more then perfect, tender, buttery, crumbly goodness!

Brittany was so friendly, she delivered my four teared cake to my venue and was super helpful!
The cake tasted wonderful and it was exactly what i was looking for to make my day perfect!

The lemon donuts here are hands down the best donuts I have EVER had! We go here often and have yet to have any treat that is not out of this world delicious! Cravings is an AWESOME small town bakery run by two amazing woman! Definitely a must try place in Cayuga! You will not be disappointed!

I would highly recommend Cravings by brittany if you are looking for great customer service, knowledge and of course delicious treats. I recently got a batman themed cake which was an absolute masterpiece no one wanted to cut into it! And a mix of chocolate peanut butter / and Rolo cupcakes. There wasn't a single person in the room who didn't have a smile on their face after enjoying a bite.
Pricing is extremely fair and on par for the quality you recieve!!
I will definately be a returning customer:)

My absolute favorite treat? It would be so hard to decide as every cake, baked good or treat I have enjoyed at Craving’s has been a joy!

Brittany’s baking reminds me of childhood and even some of my grandma’s favorites with her modern touch. I have yet to taste better baking in Haldimand County.

I highly recommend visiting her bake shop and retail space when you come to the county. You will not regret it.

Brittany is amazing !! She did our wedding cake this past September and I was blown away on her creative passion, the amazing flavours and how it was unique to our amazing day ! We continue to go in for regular treats for our family almost every weekend !

Our favourite treats for our family are her amazing butter tarts, the cannoli’s & her Nanaimo bars !! She has amazing treats for any holiday or occasion we get for friends & family to share as a delicious treat.

Love supporting this local bakery and boutique shop! Brittany and her mom are lovely and there are always unique trinkets from local artisans that catch my eye. My kids favourite treat has got to be the Heidi cookies 🍪 ❤